10 Best Sump Pump Reviews Consumer Guide & Reports (2023)

Hurricanes and Storms are pretty common in America and put the people at a risk of flooding.

Having a basement flooded with rainwater will put you and your family at health risk.

However, you can prevent your house from flooding.

Sump pumps can save your basements from getting flooded and prevent the “clean-up” fiasco which comes with a flooded basement. 

Whether your sump pump system has fallen out during a big rain event or you live in an area which is prone to flooding, either way having a good sump pump can resolve the issue.

That’s why we researched and tested hundreds of sump pumps to filter the best ones and let us tell you sump pumps not only prevent the basement from getting flooded but also be used for draining pools, lawns and anywhere you want the water to transfer.

However, after testing various sump pumps of multiple brands and analyzing consumer’s reports we came up with the best ones.

Before we move towards the important considerations, here is our top pick.

Our Best Pick

Zoeller M53 Mighty-Mate Best Submersible Sump Pump Review

Despite all the best sumps pumps of 2023 and each one having their own merits and demerits, we consider the Zoeller M53 mighty submersible pump the best sump pump one can get.

Here are some reasons why we choose this one:

  1. It doesn’t cost you a fortune.
  2. Highly durable comparatively.
  3. Best sump pump for muddy water.
  4. One can use it for both residential and commercial use.
  5. Quietest sump pump.

Comparison Table of the 10 Best Sump Pumps

Below we have compared our top picks of Sump Pumps available in the market, which are also reviewed in the later section below.

Select any two Sump Pumps from the dropdown option below in the table to compare.

Best Sump PumpsVS
1. Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump2. Wayne ESP25 Upgraded Pump3. Wayne 58321-WYN3 CDU980E Submersible Sump Pump 4. Superior Pump 91250 Submersible Utility Pump5. Superior Pump 92551 Pedestal Pump6. Liberty Pumps 257 pump7. Goplus Portable Electric Utility Pump8. Simer 2305-04 Geyser II Submersible Utility Pump9. Zoeller 105-0001 Sump Pump10. Schraiber Sump Pump for Clean/Dirty Water
Product Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review Product-Review
Type Submersible pumpBattery backup sump pump Submersible Submersible Pedestal pump Submersible Portable  pedestal sump pump Submersible sump pump Submersible sump pump Automatic 
Horsepower1/3 or 0.3HP1/3 HP3/4 HP1/4HP1/2 HP1/2HP0.1 HP0.25HP or (1/4)0.33HP1HP
GPH(gallons per hour)25000 gallons per hour2700 gallons per hour 4600 GPH (at 5 feet)1800 gallons per hour 3600 gallons per hour 50 gallons per minute 330 gallons per hour 1260 gallons per hour 2000 gallons per hour (up to 9 feet)57 gallons per minute
Construction Cast ironCast iron Stainless steel Thermoplastic Stainless steel Cast iron Stainless steel Plastic Cast iron PVC
AwardOverall bestBest battery backup sump pumpBest submersible sump pump Budget-friendly submersible pumpBest pedestal sump pump Best compact submersible sump pump Best portable sump pump Budget-friendly Best automatic sump pump Powerful sump pump 
AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on AmazonCheck on Amazon
EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on EbayCheck on Ebay
Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full ReviewJump to Full Review

Buying Guide For the Best Sump Pump

With so many options available in the market, it is quite difficult to select the best one.

We have collected some important details to consider when looking for a good sump pump according to your needs.

Let’s get straight into it…!

Buying Guide For The Best Sump Pump

1. Types Of Sump Pumps

Primarily sump pumps are of two types; submersible and pedestal and they are further categorized. 

Submersible Sump pumps

A submersible sump pump rests below your basement floor.

These sump pumps are totally submerged in the pit/sump basin and when the water is filled (up to a certain limit) in the pit, an alarm is triggered.

When a sensor is triggered, the sump pump starts its action and pumps the water outside.

Submersible Sump Pumps Reviews And Ratings

Submersible sump pumps are quieter than pedestal ones as their motors are inside the pump.

Maintenance of these pumps is a bit tricky but are safe to use around children. Also, these are a bit costly. 

Pedestal sump pumps

These are the less expensive ones but are noisy as the motor is located on a shaft above the sump.

Unlike submersible pumps which are placed in the sump basin, pedestal pumps are to be placed on the basement floor.

Pedestal Sump Pumps Reviews And Reports

Battery backup sump pumps

In case the power goes out, battery backup sump pumps provide assistance. As sumps pumps are mostly electrically powered, they will be useless when power is out, which is when you need a sump pump the most.

A battery sump pump works similarly as a standard sump pump but uses a battery instead of Mains electric power.

On an average, the battery sump pumps can pump 1000 gallons of water in a single charge but at the end of the day these are battery backed up pumps and will last only for 6-7 hours of continuous pumping (average Estimate).

Combination sump pump systems

A combination of primary electrical pump and a battery backup is a combination sump pump system. In short, all-in-one package.

These pumps provide maximum protection for all flooding hazards.

However, they are a bit bigger than standard pumps and if one has a standard sump pump basin, a combination pump may not fit.

NOTE: A standard sump pump basin is 30 inches deep, which approximately has a capacity to remove 26 to 30 gallons of water. Smaller the basin size, the more the pump will work due to filling of the basin more quickly.

2. Sump pump switch and its types

There are three types of switches, which automatically turn Off and On the pump when water reaches the certain alarming limit.

However, let’s have a closer look at the types of switches.

Switch Type Working Advantages Disadvantages
Electronic switch This switch allows the pump to start when the top sensor of the pump detects water and stops when the bottom sensor stops detecting water.This switch isn’t affected by the debris present in the water. These switches are suited to narrow pumps. Some pumps with these switches offer water depth alarms.In the long run, minerals present in the water can block the sensors. 
Tethered float These switches are very common and have a floating element which rises and falls according to the water level in the basin. These are common with sewage pumps and larger basinsA tethered float switch can travel longer than a vertical float.It requires a wide diameter sump to move freely. 
Vertical float This switch has a stem (rod) and a magnetic float. The float which fits around the stem rises and falls with the level of water and when the float reaches the switch, the magnetic force starts pumping.These are also good for narrower sumps. Vertical float travels less as compared to tethered float and resultant the pump works more.
Most Reliable Sump Pumps Reviews And Ratings From Consumer

3. Horsepower

In simple words, horsepower is a measure of a motor’s power or the ability to move things.

Or to be more precise, the power an engine produces.

Common motor sizes of a sump pump includes; 1/4HP, 1/3HP, 1/2HP and 1 HP, 1/3HP is sufficient for most of the houses but if your basement is heavily flooded, we would recommend a ½ HP pump.

4. Housing

Sump pumps are built with a variety of materials.

Affordable ones are mostly made up of plastic (high-grade) which resists wear.

High-end pumps are made up of stainless steel or iron cast which resists corrosion and are highly durable.

You ma also like to read: Best Above Ground Pools Reports and Reviews


Top 10 Best Sump Pumps (Reviews & Reports)

Here are the most reliable sump pumps of 2023.

Whether you want a submersible pump or a pedestal, the list will limit your choices. 

  • Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump
  • Wayne ESP25 Upgraded 12-Volt Battery Backup System
  • Wayne 58321-WYN3 CDU980E 3/4 HP Submersible Cast Iron and Stainless Steel Sump Pump 
  • Superior Pump 91250 1/4 HP Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump
  • Superior Pump 92551 1/2 HP Cast Iron Pedestal Pump
  • Liberty Pumps 257 pump
  • Goplus Water Transfer Pump- 115V 330 GPH Portable Electric Utility Pump
  • Simer 2305-04 Geyser II 1/4 HP Submersible Utility Pump
  • Zoeller 105-0001 Sump Pump, 12.50 x 14.50 x 14.50 inches
  • Schraiber Sump Pump for Clean/Dirty Water 1hp w/built in Automatic ON/OFF

1. Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump

Author’s Top pick.

Zoeller M53 Mighty-Mate Best Submersible Sump Pump Review

Zoeller is one of the top rated brands which is famous for making high-quality sump pumps.

Zoeller M53 mighty-mate submersible sump pump is one of them.

Given that submersible pumps spend most of their lives in murky water and damp sump pits.

So, durable sump pumps are necessary. With its cast iron material construction, the Zoeller M53 is best suited for these conditions.

Let’s have a detailed look..!

Technical Specifications

Brand Zoeller 
Material Thermoplastic base and cast iron switch
Color Green 
Power source corded electrically
Item weight 21 pounds 
Type Submersible Sump pump 
Horsepower 1/3 or 0.3HP
Dimensions 7.8 x 10.5 x 10.5 inches

Horsepower

This sump pump features a ⅓ horsepower which pumps 25,000 GPH (gallons per hour) to a height of 5 feet ideally.

Also, it can handle 30 GPM (gallons per minute) and pump it out to a height of 9 feet.

Working and Performance

This sump pump features a 3-meter long power cord and 1.5 inch NPT (National Pipe Thread) discharge.

The power cord is both safe and secure and provides minimum electric risks at the basement. 

In addition, the Zoeller M53 is powerful enough to pass the waste solids/ debris particles up to a 1.5 inches in diameter.

It comes with a large float which regulates the on/off of the switch at the depth of 19 inches.

One of the interesting features of this sump pump is, it comes with a thermal overload, which prevents the motor from getting overheated.

Unlike most of the submersible pumps which are quite tricky to install, this one surprised us with easy installation and minimum fuss.

It offers 3 years of warranty (according to the manufacturer) and according to buyers who have been using it for years consider it “buy-it-for-life”.

It will do good for 10-20 years easily (tested).

Pros

  • Strong cast iron construction.
  • The product is designed in such a way to handle it safely and easily.
  • Powerful enough to handle residential and commercial work.
  • It can handle 30 gallons of water per minute and can pump it up to the height of 9 feet.

Cons

  • The product may start leaking oil after using it for a couple of seasons.

Consumer Reports

Thousands of buyers have rated this sump with 4.7 stars out of 5.

According to most of them who have been using this pump for years now are still impressed with the quality work it is providing. 

However, some of them complained about its isolation; it may start leaking oil after using it for 5 seasons.

Our suggestion

We rate this sump pump with 9.5/10.

To sum up, the Zoeller M53 submersible pump manages to combine a sturdy design, excellent motor at a reasonable price.

No wonder, this is why most people have considered it the best submersible sump pump of 2023 for residential use.

IMPORTANT NOTE: Weep holes are important and needed to be drilled no matter what sump pump you have (irrespective of the brand). Weep holes allow the sump pumps to get free from trapped air.


2. Wayne ESP25 Upgraded 12-Volt Battery Backup Sump Pump

Best Battery Backup.

Wayne Esp25 Upgraded With Best 12-Volt Battery Backup System Review

When the power goes out due to storm raging, unless you have a whole family to rescue the basement with a bucket brigade, a battery backup sump pump system would be a good choice to keep your basement from flooding.

Just like Zoeller, Wayne is also quite famous for making durable and long lasting sump pumps.

And that’s why we came up with the Wayne ESP25 sump pump recommendation. Let’s get deep into the details.

Technical Specifications

Brand Wayne 
Material Cast iron 
Color Black 
Power source Air powered
Item weight 13.5 pounds 
Type Battery backup system 
Horsepower 1/3 HP
Dimensions 17 x 10.5 x 14 inches

NOTE: As this pump is air powered, which means the pump uses an internal floating mechanism to activate an air valve (already present inside the pump). This air valve pressurizes the pump internally to pump out the fluid.

And, when the power goes out, the pump automatically switches to the battery system to pump out the water (when needed). 

Battery power

It features a 75-Amp hour battery which can pump out 2700 GPH of pumping volume and can pump 10,000 gallons in a single charge.

Working and Performance

This sump pump is made up of cast iron construction which adds high durability factor to the machine and the top suction of this pump prevents it from airlocking.

This sump pump features a 12-Volt battery (a 12-Volt battery is considered as the best one) backup system to prevent your basement from flooding when power goes out.

Wayne Esp25 Upgraded 12-Volt Battery Backup Sump Pump System Top And Side View

It can pump 5-7 hours continuously in a single charge.

In addition, this kit comes with a water-proof protective layer on the case with an LED display and an Alarm to notify the user when the pump switches On.

Also, the smart charging feature of this pump allows the battery to remain charged at an optimal level.

These pumps come with 2 years of warranty.

Pros

  • It can easily pump out the water up to 10,000 gallons in a single charge.
  • Easy to read LED display.
  • Durable construction (cast-iron).
  • It comes with an alarm system, which notifies you when the pump switch is On.
  • Powerful pump.

Cons

  • A bit expensive.

Consumer Reports

Thousands of buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.6 stars out of 5.

This one is another top rated sump pump just like Zoeller M53.

Majority of them are satisfied with this powerful sump pump and a few of them complained about the average design of float, which is a bit loosely attached to the rod (not a deal breaker though).

Our suggestion

We rate this sump pump with 8/10.

If you are looking for a battery sump pump system, then this one would be a considerable option.

Overall, the construction and working of this sump pump is pretty good. However, it is a bit expensive.


3. Wayne 58321-WYN3 CDU980E 3/4 HP Submersible Cast Iron and Stainless Steel Sump Pump 

Best Submersible Sump Pump.

Wayne 58321-Wyn3 Cdu980E Best Submersible Cast Iron And Stainless Steel Sump Pump

This one is another sump pump of Wayne, a powerful one to be more accurate.

Comparing this one with the previous Wayne ESP25, this one is a submersible sump pump without a battery backup system.

Also, if we compare this submersible sump pump with the Zoeller M53 submersible pump, this one offers high horsepower.

Technical Specifications

Brand Wayne 
Material Stainless steel
Power source Corded electric 
Item weight 11 pounds 
Type Submersible pump 
Horsepower 3/4 HP
Dimensions 8 x 8 x 12 inches

Horsepower

The 3/4HP of the motor allows it to pump 4600 gallons of water per hour at 5 feet.

At 10 feet, the calculated flow rate is estimated as 3500 gallons per hour and at 15 feet, the flow rate is even smaller; 2550 GPH.

Working and Performance

The Wayne CDU980E is also a submersible sump pump which comes with a stainless steel housing.

However, the switch of this pump is made up of plastic which is not that durable in the long run.

Wayne 58321-Wyn3 Cdu980E Hp Best Submersible Sump Pump Side View Review

One of the interesting features of this submersible sump pump is the ease of installation and one can carry it easily.

The pump features a top suction which is tested again and again for filtering the debris to minimize the chances of clogging.

It features 1.5 inches NPT discharge, the same as Zoeller sump pump. 

As this one is also the top rated sump pump in the market, it is specifically designed for sump pits with a diameter of 11 inches or more.

Also, it comes with a vertical float switch which makes the pump switch On and Off with the help of magnetic force.

It offers 5 years of warranty.

Pros

  • Easy to install.
  • Professional grade materials.
  • 3/4HP (which makes the motor powerful).
  • Durable.

Cons

  • Some parts of this sump pump are made up of plastic (especially the switch) so don’t expect the switch to last longer.

Consumer Reports

Thousands of buyers have rated this Wayne submersible pump with 4.6 stars out of 5.

The only negative feedback reported about this one is its limited shelf life despite advertised 5-year warranty.

Other than that, this one is considered as the most powerful submersible sump pump for residential needs.

Our suggestion

We rate this sump pump with 8.5/10.

What makes it less desirable than the Zoeller submersible sump pump is its limited longevity.

However, the powerful motor it comes with really impressed us and we consider it the best power pump.


4. Superior Pump 91250 1/4 HP Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump

Budget-friendly submersible sump pump.

Superior Pump 91250 Budget Friendly Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump

This one is another submersible sump pump but comes under a low budget.

The Superior 91250 has gained a lot of attention despite the fact that it has been made up of thermoplastic material, it is also the number one seller in the market.

Technical Specifications

Brand Superior 
Material Thermoplastic 
Power source AC Mains
Item weight 6.8 pounds 
Type Submersible pump 
Horsepower 1/4HP
Dimensions 12 x 7 x 7 inches

Horsepower

This pump features 1/4HP motor which can pump out 30 gallons of water per minute or 1800 gallons of water per hour.

With this horsepower, this pump is best suited for light occasional and moderate flooding. 

Working and Performance

This pump can be used as a utility pump or a sump pump around the house.

As the name indicates itself, the superior pump is specifically designed to provide superior performance under a low budget.

It also features a capacitor for better ripple filtering, smooth working of the motor and protects the electrical system of the pump and works really great as well.

Superior Pump 91250 Budget Friendly Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump Top View Review

In addition, it comes with an easy to clean screen which removes the solid particles or debris as big as ⅛ inches.

Just like other submersible sump pumps, this one also comes with a suction top, which can be cleaned easily and increases the lifespan of thi pump. 

This pump comes with one year of limited warranty.

Furthermore, it comes with a vertical float switch which automatically turns On the unit according to water level.

Pros

  • Portable and lightweight.
  • Cheapest submersible sump pump.
  • It can work at 25 feet, which is pretty impressive for this size.
  • 1800 gallons per hour.
  • This pump can be used for both as a sump pump and a utility pump.

Cons

  • Only for smaller houses.

Consumer Reports

Thousands of buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.6 stars with 5.

According to the buyers, this one is a good deal under a low budget but if you want to get rid of water present in larger surfaces, then this one might not be a good option.

Our suggestion

We rate this sump pump with 8/10.

No doubt this one is the best seller for a reason.

However, if you have a low budget and are looking for a sump pump for moderate or light use, then you can consider this one.

However, if you place superior pump 91250 in bigger spaces or bigger homes, it will not function effectively. 


5. Superior Pump 92551 1/2 HP Cast Iron Pedestal Sump Pump

Best pedestal sump pump.

Superior Pump 92551 Cast Iron Best Pedestal Sump Pump Review And Reports

This one is another Superior sump pump and unlike the previous one, this one is a pedestal sump pump.

The construction of a pedestal pump is different from the submersible ones and offers easy maintenance unlike the latter ones.

Technical Specifications

Brand Superior 
Material Stainless steel 
Power source Corded electric 
Item weight 16.5 pounds
Type Pedestal pump 
Horsepower 1/2 HP
Dimensions 36 x 8.5 x 8.5 inches

Horsepower

The 1/2HP motor of this sump pump can easily get rid of 3600 gallons of water per hour.

Although the pedestal pumps are not as powerful as submersible ones, this one really impressed us with its output.

Working and Performance

As the pedestal pumps are above the floor level so it is easier to adjust the vertical float switch and to maintain the motor.

However, one still needs to clean the sump basin before installing it.

Still, there is minimum hassle as the motor case has less gunk around it.

Superior Pump 92551 Cast Iron Best Pedestal Sump Pump Side View

The pump is made up of stainless steel which prevents it from corrosion.

And, since this pump is to be placed on above ground, the motor makes noise but it wouldn’t be an issue if your pump doesn’t run frequently.

This pedestal pump offers 5 years of warranty, the highest warranty in the market of pedestal sump pumps.

Pros

  • Easy to maintain.
  • Long warranty.
  • Easy installation.
  • Solid build.

Cons

  • Noisy operation.

Consumer Reports

Thousands of buyers have rated this pedestal sump pump with 4.6 stars out of 5 stars ratings and is one of the best rated pumps in the market.

The majority of buyers are impressed with it till now as it offers high durability and performance.

The only problem they faced is the noise it makes while running because the motor is placed above the ground.

Our suggestion

We rate this sump pump with a 7.5/10 score.

This one is specifically for those who prefer pedestal pumps over submersible ones due to ease of maintenance.

These pumps stay away from the water below making them durable and long lasting.

Recommended: Best Toiled Bowl Cleaners Reports


6. Liberty Pumps 257 Sump pump

Best Compact submersible sump pump.

Liberty Pumps 257 Best Compact Submersible Sump Pump Review

This one is another submersible pump but from a different brand. What captured our eye about this pump is its compact construction.

The Liberty 257 pump is also one of the top rated pumps in the market which is specifically designed for compact sump basins.

Let’s have a deeper look..!

Technical Specifications

Brand Liberty pumps 
Material Cast iron 
Power source Corded electrically 
Item weight 15.22 pounds 
Type Submersible pump 
Horsepower 1/2HP
Dimensions 9.6 x 9.6 x 10.5 inches

Horsepower

The liberty 257 pump features a 1/2HP motor to pump out 50 gallons of water per minute and is designed to be compact enough to work in small sump basins.

Working and Performance

Firstly talking about its housing, the liberty 257 pump comes with a one-piece cast iron housing, which keeps the motor safe from any external damage and enhances its shelf life.

A 3 year warranty is labeled by the manufacturers.

Liberty Pumps 257 Best Compact Submersible Sump Pump Side View During Review

One of its interesting features is, the motor of this pump is thermally protected and permanently lubricated.

This unit also features a vertical float switch which can detect the water level and start On and Turn Off the pump accordingly.

However, according to some reports, some buyers faced a bit of problem adjusting the switch.

Furthermore, just like other submersible sump pumps, this one also handles 0.5 inches size of debris easily. Also, it offers 2 years of warranty.

Pros

  • It offers a heavy duty design.
  • The outer casing is covered with a bronze layer to add a high durability factor.
  • It can handle the solids up to 0.5 inches.
  • It offers a suction hose.

Cons

  • A bit expensive as compared to its competitors.

Consumer Reports

Hundreds of buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.7 stars out of 5.

Overall the performance of this sump pump is quite impressive according to the buyers.

However, a few of them complained about its vertical float switch as they faced a bit of a problem while adjusting it. 

Our suggestion

We rate this submersible sump pump with 7.5/10.

This one is specifically for those who want a sump pump for their compact sump basins (around 10 inches in diameter). 

Although this one doesn’t offer high flow rate as other submersible sumps pumps under the same price range, it provides adequate flow rate and is best suited for compact areas.


7. Goplus Water Transfer Pump

Best portable sump pump of 2023.

Goplus Water Transfer Best Portable Sump Pump Review

The next one is Goplus Water transfer Pump. Comparing this pump with other ones on the list this one offers a high portability factor and comes under a low budget. 

Not only that..!

It also offers multitasking unlike others on our list. Let’s have a look at what it has to offer.

Technical Specifications

Brand Goplus 
Material Stainless steel 
Power source Battery powered 
Item weight 5.63 pounds 
Type Pedestal (portable one)
Horsepower 0.1 HP
Dimensions 8 x 8 x 7.5 inches

Horsepower

The copper-wired premium motor offers 0.1HP to lift 330 gallons of water per hour and the maximum height it can pump out the water is about 39 feet.

One can not only pump out the water from below the ground  but also transfer it to rain barrels, pools or water tanks.

Working and Performance

As far as its performance is concerned, despite offering a high portability factor it also features a standard 3/4 inches garden hose, which makes it easier for the user to install it.

In addition, an attached suction filter prevents the unit from getting clogged.

Goplus Water Transfer Best Portable Sump Pump Top View

Also, the feature which really impressed us was the construction of this unit. Each and every part of this pump speaks about durability.

Be it Copper hose connectors, copper wire motor and stainless steel connectors, all are highly durable.

According to the manufacturers, the pump comes with an year of warranty. 

You can use this pump not only for pumping out water from the basement but also from aquariums, clogged sinks, waterbeds, blocked sinks, washing machines and so on.

Pros

  • High portability factor.
  • It offers multitasking.
  • Affordable.
  • Durable.

Cons

  • Not as powerful as others on the list.

Consumer Reports

Hundreds of buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.1 stars out of 5.

The affordability and portability factor this electric sump offers really impressed most of the users as they have been using this pump for multi-purposes for months now. 

NOTE: If you want to use it for gardening, take good care of it.

Our suggestion

We rate this sump pump with 7.5/10.

If you want something out of the box or you want a pump which can multitask and you are having a low budget, then this one would be a good consideration.


8. Simer 2305-04 Geyser II 1/4 HP Submersible Utility Pump

Budget Pick.

Simer 2305-04 Geyser Ii Submersible Utility Pump Review

This one is a budget pick for those who want a submersible sump pump but have a very low budget.

The Simer Geyser II is a good pick if you want a basement pump which can also be used for other purposes.

Let’s find out what it has to offer under a very low budget..!

Technical Specifications

Brand Simer 
Material Plastic 
Power source Battery powered 
Item weight 4.5 pounds 
Type Submersible utility pump 
Horsepower 0.25HP or (1/4)
Dimensions 7.5 x 7.5 x 12.75 inches

Horsepower

The pump offers 1/4 horsepower which allows it to pump out 1260 gallons of water per hour.

Although it doesn’t offer high flow rate but under a low budget, this is the best you can get.

Working and Performance

The Simer geyser II is made up of thermoplastic (a strong one), which makes it lightweight to carry and tough enough to handle it for most of the jobs due to its powerful 6 Amp battery.

It comes with a 8-foot power cord and garden hose connector so one can’t only use it for sump pits but also in gardens.

The installation of it is pretty easy and this is the only sump pump which comes without a switch, neither vertical nor tethered float. 

Just plug it in (in the sump pit) to start the pump or you can connect the garden hose to the cord to start it (if you are required to use it in the garden).

The 6 Amp oil-filled motor provides high efficiency and pumps out the 1260 gallons of water per hour quite efficiently. 

However, the pump offers only a 1 year warranty.

Pros

  • Cheapest sump pump in the market.
  • It offers thermal overload protection.
  • Easy to use.
  • Easy installation.

Cons

  • Some buyers have reported a short life span of it.

Consumer Reports

Hundreds of buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.1 stars out of 5.

The light and portable Simer Geyser II submersible sump pump impressed most of the buyers who were on a very low budget and wanted something substantial in a low budget. 

Our suggestion

We rate this submersible sump pump with a 7/10 score.

If you are on a very low budget and looking for a sump pump to fulfill the basic needs of pumping out the excess water from your basement, then this one would be a good option.

NOTE: In the long run, It is not highly durable as the sump pump is made up of plastic.


9. Zoeller 105-0001 Sump Pump- 19 Pound

Best Automatic sump pump.

Zoeller 105-0001 Best Automatic Sump Pump Review And Reports

This one is another Zoeller sump pump. If we compare this one with the previous ones on the list, this one is the automatic drain pump. 

The zoeller 105-0001 sump pump is equipped with all the features an automatic drain pump should have.

Let’s find out.

Technical Specifications

Brand Zoeller 
Material Cast iron 
Power source AC/DC
Item weight 30 pounds 
Type Submersible 
Horsepower 0.33HP
Dimensions 14.5 x 14.5 x 12.5 inches

Horsepower

The 0.33HP of the motor allows it to drain the gray 2000 gallons of water per hour up to 9 feet with efficiency.

At 15 feet, the flow limit drops to 1140 gallons per hour. 

Working and Performance

Being a drain up which offers high efficiency, the housing of it is pretty good as it is made up of cast iron which guarantees durability.

Whenever one feels that the water is a bit difficult to pump out (containing debris, mud and solid particles), you would find Zoeller 105-0001 a great ally in this department (tested).

Zoeller 105-0001 Best Automatic Sump Pump Top View

You can use it for garbage disposal units, dishwashers, laundry trays and obviously for sump pits/basins.

Another interesting feature of this pump is its compact design (not that compact as liberty 257 though) which allows you to install it when you don’t have enough space. 

With 1-1/2 inches of discharge port it comes with, you wouldn’t be worrying about the debris mess to deal with later on. This pump offers 1 year of warranty.

Pros

  • An automatic pump allows one to not worry about monitoring it.
  • As a drain pump, this pump offers excellent performance.
  • The polypropylene base of the pump makes it durable.
  • It comes with a 9-foot cable which allows the user to move it freely.

Cons

  • The instructions the pump comes with are not enough.
  • According to some buyers’ reports, the valve is a bit loud.

Consumer Reports

Hundreds of buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.7 stars out of 5.

According to the majority of them, they considered it well-functioning and durable.

Some Of them complained about the noise that erupted from the pump’s valve.

Our suggestion

We rate this automatic sump pump with 8/10.

If you are looking for an automatic drain pump without worrying about monitoring it again and again, then this one would be a good option.


10. Schraiber Sump Pump for Clean/Dirty and Muddy Water

Powerful sump pump.

Schraiber Sump Pump For Clean And Dirty Muddy Water Review

Lastly, we have Schraiber sump pump recommendation which is the most powerful pump of our list. 

One can control this pump both automatically and manually. Let’s have a deeper look at the details.

Technical Specifications

Brand Schraiber Pump
Material PVC
Power source Corded electrically 
Item weight 14.59 pounds
Type Automatic pump
Horsepower 1HP
Dimensions 16 x 9 x 9 inches

Horsepower

The 1HP of the motor allows it to pump out the 57 gallons of water per minute up to 26 feet.

Also, the pump can pull out water automatically at 5’’ (to pump out standing water) and can manually pump the water at the lowest starting level from 7’’.

Working and Performance

As far as its performance is concerned, the pump comes with an automatic switch which turns the pump On and Off automatically.

No external float switch is present nor required.

This pump can also be used to pump out the standing water and can pump it at the level of 5’’.

Pretty impressive though. Also, one can use this pump manually also depending upon the need of it. 

When the place gets dry, the pump will automatically turn off after a minute. And, it offers 2 years of warranty.

Pros

  • Highest horsepower.
  • Automatic.
  • Easy to use.
  • This pump can help remove standing water at 5-7 inches also.

Cons

  • Some of you might find this pump a bit pricey.

Consumer Reports

Buyers have rated this sump pump with 4.2 stars out of 5.

According to them this one is a small powerful sump pump which can pump water very quickly due to its fast motor and can also be used for other purposes.

Our suggestion

We rate this sump with a 7.5/10 score.

If you are someone looking for a sump pump which can pump out the water very quickly and also drain the standing water accumulated in front of the garage after heavy rainfall, then this one would be a considerable option.


Honorable Mention

As we couldn’t mention more sump pumps as we wanted to so here is the bonus edition of a Combination sump pump.

Zoeller 508-0006 Aquanot 508 ProPak53 Preassembled Sump Pump

Zoeller 508-0006 Aquanot 508 Propak53 Preassembled Sump Pump System With Good Battery Back-Up

This is the combination sump pump which comes with a primary pump (submersible) and is backed up with a battery system.

It can pump out 2100 gallons of water per hour (primary pump) and when the pump is running on a battery system it can pump 2040 GPH up to 10 feet.

When the primary pump fails to function or power outages, the battery system can run straight for about 6 hours.

Also, the construction of the pump is of cast iron to provide high durability.


FAQs

Here are some commonly asked questions regarding these sump pumps.

What Is A Sump Pump And How Does It Work?

A sump pump is a device which pulls out the water from a sump basin, mainly located/ found in the basement of houses. It protects the property from flooding and water buildup.

Not only that, if you have an excess amount of moisture in your house’s foundation, a sump pump can help.

Working; when a certain amount of water reaches, the pit beneath the structure collects the water and pumps it out of the premises.

Running of a sump pump depends upon the amount of water your basement has.

Which one is better: Wayne or Zoeller sump pumps?

The biggest difference between these two pumps is; the amount of water the pump can move and size of debris it can handle.

Wayne pumps are famous for pumping water at a higher rate but do not pass solids of larger size.

On the other hand, Zoeller sump pumps pump  the water at a slower rate but can pass larger solids/debris easily.

Who makes the best sump pumps?

Zoeller and Wayne make the best sump pumps and both are famous and best sellers in the market due to the quality products they offer. 

What is the difference between Liberty 257 and Zoeller M53 sump pump?

Zoeller M53 and Liberty 257 sump pumps have one thing in common, which is that both can handle solid particles up to 0.5 inches easily and thus making them good for removing dirty water containing debris and solid particles.

However, Zoeller M53 is more durable and powerful if we compare all the features deeply. 

How to maintain a sump pump?

Most of the models in the market either a submersible or pedestal, require low maintenance.

However, one should clean the inlet screen and check the power cord once every four months.

You should also consider the fact that no matter what brand of a sump pump you have, every sump pump requires maintenance.

The bearings of the pump should also be oiled or greased often to have smooth performance.

In addition, if you have a battery backup sump pump, consider changing the battery after every 4 years. 


Final Words

Flooded basements are frustrating especially when one can’t figure out how to get rid of dirty/murky water instantly.

That’s why the sump pumps are the best solution.

We have mentioned a variety of sump pump types which are the best sellers and top rated ones.

Whether you want a pedestal one to save yourself from difficult installation or want a submersible one without worrying about the noise, you can get anything you like according to your requirements.

However, we prefer submersible pumps (as they are quiet and require less tension to start them) compared to pedestal ones and the best features to consider while making a choice is the material and the horsepower. 

We hope the list we have mentioned helped you to minimize your choices to one or two.

Still, if you face any ambiguity regarding the topic, you can shoot us with queries.

Submit Your Report

We would love to hear from you and read your own reports to help others..!

Submit Report

Connect

Subscribe

Join our email list to receive the latest reports.