Gas fireplaces are the best alternatives when you need to feel the warmth and light of a natural/traditional fireplace. The gas fireplaces offer less maintenance than electric fireplaces and traditional fireplaces.
Gas fireplaces are more efficient than electric fireplaces and they can warm up large spaces due to high heat output. The gas fireplaces manufactured nowadays look like traditional ones and sometimes it is hard to know the difference between them.
However, there are multiple gas fireplaces in the market right now with further multiple types of it as well. Choosing the best one among them is a pretty daunting task. In this article, we will guide you deeply on how to choose the best one and which type is suitable for who and under what condition.
Whether you are looking for gas fireplace insert, gas fireplace, vented or ventless, we have got you covered.
So, let’s dive in…!
Comparison of the Top Rated Gas Fireplaces
Below we have compared out top picks of Gas Fireplaces which are also reviewed in the later section below. So, make sure to check the whole reviews as well.
Select any two Gas Fireplaces from the dropdown option below in the table to compare.
| Best Gas Fireplaces | VS | |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Duluth Forge Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert | 2. Pleasant Hearth Gas Log Set | |
| Product | 
| 
|
| BTU | 32000 BTU/ hour | 33000 BTU/ hour |
| Vented or Ventless | Ventless | Ventless |
| Installation type | Insert | Log set |
| Heating capacity (area-wise) | 1500 sq.ft | 1100 sq.ft |
| Best for | Author’s choice | Best ceramic gas logs |
| Amazon | Check on Amazon | Check on Amazon |
| Ebay | Check on Ebay | Check on Ebay |
| Full Review | Jump to Full Review | Jump to Full Review |
#1 Pick
Duluth Forge Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert is the #1 Best Gas Fireplace in our list.
Consumer Guide for Choosing a Good Gas Fireplace
Here is the detailed guide for you to make a better choice when purchasing a gas fireplace.
Types of Gas Fireplaces; Everything you need to know
People often get confused with the three terms; gas fireplaces, gas fireplaces inserts and gas logs and then often use them interchangeably. That’s not the true case though. We will guide you the main difference among them so you can have better invasion.
1. Gas Fireplaces
The typical gas fireplaces use fuel (natural gas or propane) to make real flames unlike electric fireplaces. But, you don’t have to burn the wood to get flames and hustle of ashes just like traditional flames.
These fireplaces are constructed in the wall and don’t need a chimney or pre-existing fireplace like an insert one.
2. Gas Fireplace insert
These fireplaces are the modern version of gas fireplaces. Just like the name indicates, these are inserted inside the pre-existing places or in existing chimneys. The firebox of this fireplace emits the heat by burning fuel.
These are the user-friendly options available in the market right now.
Gas Logs
These types of fireplaces are the cheapest options and are recommended to those who want to experience the feel of “burning wood”. Gas logs are basically ceramic logs which are designed skillfully and artfully to not touch the gas burner.
However, they are the cheapest options but not the efficient ones. Still, they have high aesthetics.
Vented gas fireplaces vs Ventless
The types of gas fireplaces mentioned above further come with vented or ventless models. These types are further categorized as well. Let’s get into the details.
a) Vented gas fireplaces
The gas fireplaces with vented models use outside air for combustion. These models don’t allow any cold air to get inside the house and heat up the environment faster. Such models are further categorized into 3 types.
1. Natural vented (B-Vent)
The natural vented models of gas fireplaces use the inside air of the room and then release the emissions outside the home. These models can easily be used without electricity unlike direct vent systems.
The air passed through a chimney or vent pipes to the outside of the home, the vents can be installed vertically or horizontally depending upon the gas fireplace model. However, these are less efficient but are capable of making attractive flames.
Natural vents although offer high ambiance but cost you run the furnace more frequently.
2. Direct Vent
Direct venting systems are the most efficient method to send off the combustion fumes and air pollutants as well outside the home. Even most of the homeowners prefer a direct venting system and these vents can be installed in any place in your home.
Most of the vented gas fireplaces come with direct vented models and are 70 to 85% efficient in terms of heating.
3. Power Dent
These are not commonly used nowadays as they are not as efficient as others and use a powered-fan in order to exchange the heat. However, these are good to use when needed to travel heat at a long distance.
b) Ventless gas fireplaces
Ventless gas fireplace as the name indicates itself doesn’t need any venting system to exchange the heat. These models use inside air and emit the same air in the room as well. Furthermore, these models don’t use any electricity to turn On the vent.
In fact, such models have sensors installed in them which automatically turn Off the fireplace when the temperature gets too hot.
OUR OPINION: If you are looking for high heating efficiency for larger spaces then Ventless ones would be the best option. And, for vented fireplaces, direct vent gas fireplaces are the best ones.
After you have chosen the type of gas fireplace you need for your home, another important consideration is the BTU (heat output). Although the gas fireplaces have higher heat outputs than electric fireplaces still it depends upon your personal choice according to your area.
On an average, for every one square foot space/place, a 20 BTU heat output is necessary for efficient performance.
8 Best Gas Fireplaces (Reviews & Reports)
After in depth research and testing multiple gas fireplaces of all types, we came up with the best ones.
1. Duluth Forge Dual Fuel Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert
Author’s choice.
Let’s start the list with the ventless gas fireplaces. This one is the insert type which you can easily fit in the pre-existing fireplace without a venting system. There is more to this gas fireplace and let’s dive more into it.
Specifications
| Brand | Duluth forge |
| Material | Ceramic |
| Color | Black |
| Installation type | Built-in |
| Type | Ventless insert |
| Heating capacity with respect to are | 1500 sq.ft. |
| Heat output | 32000 BTU/ hour |
| Dimensions | 15 x 29 x 29 inches |
Overall Overview
This gas fireplace insert comes with the front door and 6 built-in logs which are designed realistically and hand painted by professionals to create a real look. This gas fireplace uses dual fuel technology so one can choose Natural gas or propane as per one’s convenience.
You can operate the fireplace from the thermostat as this one uses electricity to operate. When plugged in you can set the thermostat which further uses natural gas or propane to heat the ceramic logs.
Furthermore, it comes with a built-in Oxygen depletion sensor (ODS) which allows the fireplace to turn Off automatically when the levels of Oxygen depletes and Mono carbon dioxide increases.
It offers 32000 BTU of heat output despite having a small size and can warm up the environment with 99% efficiency. In addition, it can heat the area up to 1500 sq.ft.
Pros
- It uses both natural gas or propane.
- It is 99% efficient.
- Good for small apartments.
- It automatically shuts Off when overheating.
- Natural gas fireplace insert (for those who are looking for this feature the most).
Cons
- No remote control.
Consumers report
Consumers have rated this gas fireplace with 4.2 stars out of 5.
The buyers who have been using this insert gas fireplace are pretty satisfied with this fireplace. The size of it is small and is highly efficient. Overall the feedback was positive and customer’s didn’t complain about anything as such.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace insert with a 9 score out of 10.
In our opinion, if you are looking for a gas fireplace insert with less dedicated space in your home, then this ventless gas fireplace would be a considerable option. Also, we consider it the best gas fireplace due to its efficient performance as per our testing.
2. Pleasant Hearth Gas Log Set
The next one is a Pleasant Hearth gas log set for those who prefer a live “wood-burning” look. This one is another ventless gas fireplace which can be used indoors and outdoors as well. For further details, let’s have a look at the details.
Specifications
| Brand | Pleasant hearth |
| Material | Oak |
| Color | Brownish-gray |
| Installation type | Freestanding |
| Type | Gas logs |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | 1100 sq.ft |
| Heat output | 33000 BTU/ hour |
| Dimensions | 13.5″D x 24″W x 12.25″H |
Overall Overview
The 8 piece logs of this gas fireplace are made up of concrete and hand-painted to give a natural look. You can place this gas log indoor at any place or place it outside as well as it is freestanding type.
In addition, it comes with a thermostat remote control which turns it On/Off by clicking the button. No need to use electricity in case of emergency situations. Just like the previous one, this one also uses dual fuel technology so you can choose Natural gas or propane.
It offers 33000 BTU of heat output and can heat the area up to 1100 sq.ft. comparing it with the previous ventless one, this one is less efficient but still can heat the place of 1100 sq.ft pretty efficiently.
Pros
- Good for indoor and outdoors.
- Easy to assemble.
- Realistic look.
- Budget-friendly.
Cons
- The quality of the gas valve could have been a bit better.
Consumers report
Consumers have rated this gas log with 4 stars out of 5.
The buyers who have been using this gas fireplace for months now are pretty impressed with the stylish looks and design of it. The flames of it are quite impressive and the overall feedback is positive.
The gas valve of this fireplace has a bit of compromised quality which irked a few customers.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with an 8.5 score out of 10.
If you have a low budget and want to enjoy the realistic look of burning wood, then this one would be a considerable option. Furthermore, you don’t need any kind of venting system for its installation as it is a freestanding one.
Recommended Read: Best Cheap Log Splitters Reports
3. Empire Comfort Systems Direct-Vent gas fireplace
This one is a Vented option for those who are looking for high aesthetics and high efficiency (among vented ones). This one is a direct vented type which allows the air pollutants in the air to get out of the house as well.
Comparing this model with its predecessors, this one offers a strong build with high aesthetics.
Specifications
| Brand | Empire comfort systems |
| Material | Tempered glass, ceramic, glass |
| Color | Black |
| Installation type | Freestanding |
| Type | Direct vent |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | 1100 sq.ft. |
| Heat output | 26000 BTU/ hour |
| Dimensions | 19.88 x 39 x 37.63 inches |
Overall Overview
As we have mentioned before, direct vented gas fireplaces are the most efficient ones and are mostly preferred by the homeowners. You can insert this model horizontally or vertical depending upon your personal preferences.
This vented gas fireplace offers 26000 BTU of heat output and can cover 1100 sq.ft area. Despite offering less heat output, it is more efficient than other direct vented options in the market.
However, this one is good for small and shallow places as it is 19 inches deep. When we tested it personally, the door and frame of it gets hot (as it is made up of glass material) when used for a long time. For that, we would recommend you to opt for a protective glass barrier.
Pros
- Easy installation.
- Good build.
- You can install it vertically or horizontally.
- You can use the outside air for combustion as well.
Cons
- Only natural gas.
- Gets heat up after prolonged usage.
Consumers report
Consumers have rated this fireplace with 4.2 stars out of 5.
As per the reports, the buyers responded with positive feedback due to ease of installation. Also, the feasibility to install horizontally or vertically. Overall, the feedback is good except the glass material gets hot.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with an 8.5 score out of 10.
If you are looking for a direct vented gas fireplace to be placed in a shallow place, then this one would be a considerable option. Overall the performance of this vented fireplace is quite impressive as compared to other vented (direct vented) fireplaces.
You may also like: Best Cheap Wood Chippers Reports
4. Empire Comfort Systems Deluxe B-Vent Fireplace
This one is another Empire comfort system gas fireplace and unlike the previous one, it is vented naturally (B-vent). This one’s specifically made for small and compact areas.
Specifications
| Brand | Empire comfort system |
| Material | Metal |
| Color | Dark gray |
| Installation type | Vented (B-vent) |
| Type | B-vent type |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | 300 sq.ft. |
| Heat output | 21000 BTU/ hour |
| Dimensions | 14.87″D x 37″W x 35.62″H |
Overall Overview
Unlike the previous one, this one is installed vertically only (B-vent) and uses natural gas only to ignite the fireplace. The interesting feature of this B-vented gas fireplace is, it comes with logs as well to give you a traditional and modern look at the same time.
It offers 21000 BTU heat output which is good for small places. This natural vent model doesn’t warm up the temperature of the room excessively like some direct vent models.
Pros
- Stylish design.
- The flickering of flames are prolonged.
- It doesn’t overheat the room.
- It comes with a log set as well.
Cons
- Good for small places only.
Consumers report
Consumers have rated this gas fireplace with 4 ratings out of 5.
As per the reports, the only drawback of this gas fireplace is, it is good for confined places and can be ignited electrically as well. The design of it is quite impressive and they praised its design.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with an 8 score out of 10.
This one offers a traditional and modern look at the same time and is considered as the best Natural vented gas fireplace. Comparing it with other models, this one offers high ambiance.
5. Duluth Forge Ventless Linear Wall Gas Fireplace
This one is another Duluth ventless gas fireplace and unlike the previous one, this one is wall mounted. This one is another gas fireplace for small apartments but is highly efficient. Let’s have a look at the details.
Specifications
| Brand | Duluth |
| Material | Ceramic |
| Color | Black |
| Installation type | Built in and Wall mount |
| Type | Ventless |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | 1400 sq.ft |
| Heat output | 26000 BTU/hour |
| Dimensions | 7.84″D x 27.95″W x 18.05″H |
Overall Overview
If we compare this unit with other models mentioned above and its predecessors, this one offers instant heat when turned On. Also, you can mount it on the wall or fit it in any vacant place in your home.
If we talk about the performance of it, it heats up the environment pretty well despite having less BTU output than others. Duluth has done a pretty good job in maintaining the heating quality of this unit and we are quite impressed.
It looks like a traditional gas heater with grills in front and ceramic logs present inside it. One can control the unit with thermostat control. For those who look for remote control, it doesn’t come with any.
Pros
- Slim design.
- Efficient thermostat control.
- Highly efficient.
- Instant heating.
Cons
- A bit difficult to install.
Consumers report
Consumers have rated this gas fireplace with 4 stars out of 5.
The users who have been using this gas fireplace only faced the installation issue as the installation guide is not clearly explained. Also, a few buyers complained about some broken logs on arrival.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with an 8 score out of 10.
If you are looking for a gas fireplace for instant heating and want to mount it on the wall, then this one would be a considerable option.
6. AMERICAN HEARTH Boulevard Direct Vent Linear Fireplace
The next recommendation is the American Hearth Vented fireplace. This one is for those who want to heat larger places and have enough dedicated space. The aesthetics and stylish design of it set it apart from others.
Specifications
| Brand | American Hearth |
| Material | Glass |
| Color | Multicolor |
| Installation type | Wall mounted |
| Type | Direct vent |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | 1800 sq.ft |
| Heat output | 50000 BTU/hr (Natural gas)52000 BTU/hr (propane) |
| Dimensions | 21.5″D x 81″W x 38.25″H |
Overall Overview
If we compare this gas fireplace with others, it comes with a 72 inches frame made up of high tempered glass material. It looks exactly like an LED screen but with a sleek design. Also, this one is a direct vented type, and unlike the previous one (Duluth Forge), it is good for large spaces.
This direct vented is mounted on the wall and can easily warm up the space up to 1800 sq.ft. and is more efficient than other vented fireplaces. In addition, the description of this product says it only uses Natural gas as a fuel but in reality, it uses both; Natural gas and propane.
Pros
- Good for big rooms.
- Multi-function remote control.
- It comes with a barrier screen also
- High aesthetics.
Cons
- The decorative media is sold separately.
Consumers report
Consumers have rated this gas fireplace with 4.5 stars out of 5.
Those who have been using this gas fireplace for months now are still impressed and pretty content with its high aesthetics and overall performance. The negative feedback we received was very minimal.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with an 8.5 score out of 10.
If you are looking for a gas fireplace for your big house or for large spaces, then this direct vented gas fireplace would be a considerable option.
7. Stanbroil Large Ceramic Gas Logs
This one is another gas log entry but set for outdoors. Unlike the previous one mentioned above (gas log), this one is a 10 piece log set with variable sizes to offer you the realistic wood fireplace.
Specifications
| Brand | Stanbroil |
| Material | Ceramic wood |
| Color | Gray |
| Installation type | Any ventless installation |
| Type | Ventless |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | For outdoors |
| Heat output | 50000 BTU |
| Dimensions | 16.26 x 11.18 x 7.17 inches |
Overall Overview
When we tested these logs, the construction and design of it really looks like wooden logs but when you look at it closely, they were made up of ceramic wood. However, you can place it in a pre-existing firebox or wooden fireplace as well or in your lawn.
Furthermore, it offers high heat output suited for medium to large spaces and offers a good ambiance as well.
Pros
- Easy installation.
- Good ceramic wood logs quality.
- Best for outdoors.
- The flames give a real look.
- Light in weight.
Cons
- Sometimes the logs start to burn and produce ashes when used for a prolonged time period.
Consumers report
Hundreds of consumers have rated this gas fireplace with 4.4 stars out of 5.
The ease of installation and realistic look of a wooden fireplace impressed the majority of customers. Also, these gas fireplace logs look real like wood logs when burnt and offer good flames as well.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with a 7.5 score out of 10.
If you are looking for gas logs for bigger places under a low budget, then this one would be a good option to consider.
8. ProCom Dual Fuel Ventless Gas Fireplace
Last but not the least, we present ProCom dual fuel ventless fire with a wooden frame in which a gas fireplace is placed. Comparing it with others, it comes with a wooden mantel frame on which you can place things (decorations etc.).
Specifications
| Brand | ProCom |
| Material | Cast Iron |
| Color | Apple spice |
| Installation type | Freestanding |
| Type | Ventless |
| Heating capacity with respect to area | 1350 sq.ft |
| Heat output | 26000 BTU/hour |
| Dimensions | 15 x 48 x 40 inches |
Overall Overview
This model doesn’t need any chimney or venting system to install it just like any other ventless gas fireplace. It comes in a freestanding position which you can place anywhere you want and can easily control it by a remote control.
Moreover, it comes with a built-in ODS (Oxygen depletion Sensor) which shuts down the gas fireplace when Oxygen is limited in the room. It features dual fuel technology so you can use Natural gas or Liquid Propane as per your preference.
Pros
- It offers dual fuel technology.
- Built-in style within a wooden frame.
- It automatically shuts down when the desired temperature reaches.
- Can be placed anywhere in the house.
Cons
- A bit heavier.
Consumers report
The Consumers who have been using this fireplace for a while now rated it with 4.6 stars out of 5.
The build of it is constructed really well and offers high sturdiness. Its ease of usage impressed users the most. Also, it doesn’t need any chimney nor venting system installed.
Our suggestion
We rate this gas fireplace with an 8.5 score out of 10.
This one is the best freestanding ventless gas fireplace one can get right now in the market. This one is good for medium sized homes.
How to Turn On a Gas Fireplace?
Turning On the gas fireplaces is pretty simple. For that, open the front door of your gas fireplace (if it has any as a lot of models don’t come with any front door) and turn On the “pilot knob” and hold it for a while.
Hold the knob for some seconds as the gas in the fireplace will direct into the pilot and then press the “igniting” button until it lits. If the model doesn’t come with any ignition button, then you can use a match box as well.
With a wall key
Nowadays, mostly gas fireplaces use an ignition button to ignite the fire in a pilot. The older models use wall keys to ignite the fire. Enter the wall key in the gas valve (after finding it) and rotate it counter-clockwise for a while and light the match stick or lighter and Turn it On.
TIP: Rotate the wall key slowly before igniting the fire or you will burn the whole place if rotated the wall key to its full.
FAQs
How to clean a gas fireplace?
Cleaning your gas fireplace from time to time not only enhances its outer look but also improves the overall efficiency of the unit. However, it would be best to clean the unit with a soft brush and if you see any adamant stain then use a bit of alcohol on the brush and wipe it off.
How much gas does a gas fireplace use?
Well, the consumption varies from model to model and brand to brand. On an average, a fireplace uses 1 gallon of natural gas or propane per hour.
How much does it cost to install a gas fireplace?
It depends upon the type of installation. If you want to install it in the pre-existing fireplace, then the whole cost would be around $1500. And, if you want to install it for the first time then it will cost you more than that (around $4500 and more).
Can you burn wood in a gas fireplace?
No! Gas fireplaces are introduced in the first place to not burn the wood but burns the gas only. Hence no hassle of cleaning the burnt ash.
Does a gas fireplace need a chimney?
Well, you don’t need a chimney unless you want to insert it in the pre-existing fireplace. The models are either vented or ventless. Vented models need venting systems and ventless ones need neither of them. So, in either case, you don’t need a chimney for gas fireplaces.
Conclusion
Gas fireplaces are the best alternatives of traditional wood burning fireplaces with good ambiance and not worrying about cleaning up the ashes. The gas fireplaces offer higher efficiency than electric fireplaces (other alternatives).
We have mentioned all the gas fireplaces above so you can choose the best one according to your budget, need or preferences. In our opinion, ventless gas fireplaces are more efficient than vented ones.
However, if you are having any trouble regarding making a decision, feel free to ask us.
